In recent public discussions, particularly as the 2025 school board elections approach, some vocal critics have targeted diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs in our schools, claiming these efforts are “divisive” and “detrimental.” Right-wing hate groups often argue that they foster hate, division, and indoctrination. However, these arguments not only misrepresent the goals of DEI initiatives but also overlook the fundamental values upon which our nation was founded. The reality is that DEI programs benefit everyone, not just specific groups, and align with the Coloradan ideals of freedom, liberty, and justice for all.

A Country For All

We must recognize that we are living on land that has long been cared for by Indigenous tribes, whose cultures and traditions have celebrated and honored gender beyond the binary of man and woman. Many Indigenous communities recognize Two-Spirit individuals, who embody a unique blend of masculine and feminine qualities, as highly respected members of their communities. These Indigenous traditions show that the acceptance of diverse gender identities is not a new or foreign concept, but rather a longstanding and integral part of the human experience. By acknowledging and honoring these truths, we can better reflect the inclusivity and respect that our country—and particularly Colorado—should strive to embody.

The United States was founded by immigrants in pursuit of religious freedom, liberty, and justice. These ideals are embedded in the very fabric of our nation. The idea that some citizens do not belong here, based on their race, gender identity, or sexual orientation, contradicts the core American values of inclusivity, opportunity, and prosperity. Coloradans have deeply held onto these values as we have worked collectively the last three decades to redeem “The Hate State”. It is critical that we uphold this legacy by ensuring that all people are treated with respect and dignity.

When we acknowledge issues affecting vulnerable populations, we are not creating opportunities for “indoctrination” but allowing students to gain empathy and have critical thought of those in our country who have had different experiences than theirs. These are the lived experiences of many who are too often silenced.

The efforts to raise awareness about the struggles of Black communities through movements like Black Lives Matter, to advance the rights of people with disabilities as seen in the powerful activism of the Gang of 19 and the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), or to recognize the rights of LGBTQIA+ individuals, are not about creating division—they are about human rights.

Embracing diversity, equity, and inclusion does not come at the expense of anyone else. It is possible to affirm the dignity of all people, regardless of their race, gender identity, or sexual orientation, without taking away from anyone else.

These movements ask for basic recognition: to be seen, heard, and treated as human beings, with the same rights and opportunities as anyone else. These are not radical ideologies—they are calls for equal treatment. We all deserve to live the lives that we want to live. When one of us rises, we all rise.

DEI Programs are Not Zero-Sum

The false narrative used to create fear of DEI programs often suggests that the inclusion of historically marginalized groups somehow diminishes opportunities or rights for others. This is a false premise. Embracing diversity, equity, and inclusion does not come at the expense of anyone else. It is possible to affirm the dignity of all people, regardless of their race, gender identity, or sexual orientation, without taking away from anyone else.

Black Lives Matter does not diminish the lives of others—it emphasizes the need for justice where it has been historically absent. LGBTQIA+ rights do not take away from the rights of heterosexual or cisgender individuals—they expand the rights of everyone to live authentically. These are not ideologies that create enemies or instill fear; they are movements that seek to broaden the circle of compassion, equity, and fairness for everyone.

Education, Not Indoctrination

We all want to live in a world with free access to information and the opportunity to think things through for ourselves. The argument against DEI programs often centers around the fear of indoctrination or forcing people to believe in one set of ideas without questioning. This is intentionally misleading information used to silence oppressed groups.

In reality, far right groups are the ones keeping us divided, not DEI programs. DEI programs are rooted in education and awareness. They encourage critical thinking, self-awareness, and empathy—qualities that are essential to creating a more just and equitable society. The more we learn about those who have had different experiences than our own the more we are able to come together. 

Teaching students about the history of racial injustice, gender inequality, and LGBTQIA+ rights is not indoctrination—it is education. Understanding these issues prepares young people to engage with the world as informed, empathetic citizens. It helps them recognize the dignity of others, while also reinforcing the values of equality and fairness that are essential to the functioning of a democracy.

Moving Toward Unity, Not Division

The primary purpose of DEI programs is not to divide us but to bring us together. They ask us to confront uncomfortable truths about our shared history and to recognize the ongoing struggles of many in our society. In doing so, we learn to treat one another with more respect and understanding. It is not about forcing everyone to adopt the same identity, but about making space for all identities to coexist peacefully and respectfully.

Ultimately, fostering diversity, equity, and inclusion benefits everyone—not just marginalized groups. It builds stronger communities, improves interpersonal relations, and enriches the educational experience. When we make room for everyone to be seen, heard, and respected, we create stronger, more resilient communities.

In the face of growing polarization, it is more important than ever to remember that the strength of our country lies in its diversity. DEI programs are not a threat to the American way of life; they are a reaffirmation of the principles upon which this nation was founded: liberty, justice, and the pursuit of happiness for all.

Our youth in Colorado understand the importance of inclusion over division, and they don’t overcomplicate things. As one youth told us:

“To help everyone feel included I think it’s easiest to keep an open mind. Being able to think of everyone in a new environment and be open to learning about each other.”

Developing empathetic, thoughtful, and open minded youth is a goal that all Coloradans have an opportunity to come together on. DEI initiatives are about just that; creating a society where every individual can live authentically and freely, a society that honors the fundamental promise of the United States: freedom and justice for ALL.

Cal Solverson is the Development and Communications Manager at One Colorado, the state’s leading LGBTQIA+ advocacy organization.